NewTop OIG Audit Targets Every Physician Should Know
The Provider Partner
Uncategorized

Top OIG Audit Targets Every Physician Should Know

Tracy
Top OIG Audit Targets Every Physician Should Know

Top OIG Audit Targets Every Physician Should Know

If the Government Looked at Your Claims Tomorrow, What Would Your Data Say About You?

Most physicians don't wake up thinking about the Office of Inspector General.

They're thinking about patients.

Surgeries.

Hospital rounds.

Documentation.

Staffing.

Prior authorizations.

And somehow getting home at a reasonable hour.

But every claim your practice submits creates data—and government oversight agencies can use claims data to identify unusual billing patterns and areas at risk for improper payment.

The HHS Office of Inspector General (OIG) Work Plan is dynamic and updated as OIG adds, changes, and completes audit and evaluation projects. oig.hhs.gov

That means compliance shouldn't start when you receive an audit letter.

It should start by understanding where your practice may have risk.

Here are some of the most important areas physicians should be watching.


1. Modifier 25

If there is one modifier that deserves your attention, it's Modifier 25.

Modifier 25 tells the payer that a significant, separately identifiable E/M service was performed by the same physician or other qualified healthcare professional on the same day as another procedure or service.

The problem?

It can be misused to generate an additional E/M payment when the work performed was actually part of the procedure.

And OIG continues to examine this area.

In a recent audit involving E/M services billed on the same day as intravitreal eye injections, OIG reviewed 24 sampled E/M services and found that documentation for 22 did not support use of Modifier 25. OIG reported that Medicare had paid approximately $124 million nationally for E/M services with Modifier 25 on the same day as these injections during the audit period. oig.hhs.gov

OIG has also reported concerns involving Modifier 25 in specialties such as podiatry and dermatology. oig.hhs.gov

What should you audit?

Look for providers who:

  • Use Modifier 25 at unusually high rates
  • Report an E/M with nearly every minor procedure
  • Use identical documentation repeatedly
  • Don't clearly separate the E/M work from the procedure
  • Automatically append Modifier 25 through billing edits

The question isn't:

“Did we perform an office visit?”

It's:

“Was there a significant, separately identifiable E/M service supported by the documentation?”


2. High-Level E/M Coding

High-level E/M codes aren't bad.

Complex patients require complex care.

But unusually high utilization deserves attention.

If one physician's coding distribution looks dramatically different from peers, that doesn't prove anything improper occurred.

It creates a question.

Why?

Maybe the physician treats more complex patients.

Maybe the provider works in a tertiary-care environment.

Maybe the patient population has greater acuity.

Or maybe the documentation doesn't support the codes being reported.

The only way to know is to audit.

OIG has historically scrutinized E/M coding and continues to examine whether documentation and billing comply with Medicare requirements. oig.hhs.gov

Don't respond by automatically downcoding.

That's not compliance either.

Instead:

Benchmark → Identify outliers → Review records → Educate → Re-audit.


3. Incident-To Billing

This should be on the radar of any physician practice using nonphysician practitioners or clinical staff under Medicare's incident-to rules.

OIG currently has an active Work Plan project examining whether Medicare Part B payments for services billed incident to physicians' services complied with Medicare requirements. OIG notes that qualifying incident-to services are billed under the physician's NPI as though the physician personally furnished them and, in general, are subject to direct-supervision and other requirements. oig.hhs.gov

That's important because the claim itself may not tell the entire story about who actually performed the service.

Practices should audit:

  • Who performed the service?
  • Whose NPI was used?
  • Were applicable supervision requirements met?
  • Was the service eligible for incident-to billing?
  • Was the plan of care established and maintained as required?
  • Does the documentation support the billing arrangement?

Don't assume that because your EHR allows you to bill under the physician, Medicare rules allow it.


4. Medical Necessity

A CPT code can be technically correct and still create a compliance problem.

Why?

Because the service also needs to satisfy applicable coverage and medical-necessity requirements.

This is particularly important when practices repeatedly perform high-volume services.

Think:

Was the service performed?

Yes.

Was it coded correctly?

Yes.

Was it medically necessary and supported?

That's the next question.

Your compliance audit shouldn't stop at CPT accuracy.


5. Modifier 59 and NCCI Edits

Here's a workflow that should make every compliance officer nervous:

Claim denies.

Someone adds Modifier 59.

Claim pays.

Problem solved.

Except maybe it wasn't.

Modifier 59 and the applicable X{EPSU} modifiers aren't simply tools for making payer edits disappear.

They communicate specific circumstances supporting distinct reporting.

Historically, OIG has examined the use of modifiers to bypass National Correct Coding Initiative edits because inappropriate modifier use can result in payment for services that otherwise would not be separately payable. oig.hhs.gov

Audit your override modifiers.

Ask:

Why was the modifier added?

Who added it?

What documentation supported it?

Was it present before the denial—or added afterward simply to obtain payment?

That last question can uncover some uncomfortable workflows.


6. Telehealth and Virtual Services

Telehealth isn't the temporary billing experiment it once was.

But the rules continue to evolve.

That makes telehealth an area practices need to monitor carefully.

OIG has conducted multiple reviews of Medicare telehealth services and recently completed work examining virtual check-ins and e-visits, identifying opportunities for stronger safeguards and provider education. oig.hhs.gov

Importantly, OIG has also found substantial compliance in some telehealth audits. In one review of Medicare E/M telehealth services, 105 of 110 sampled services complied with Medicare requirements. oig.hhs.gov

That's an important reminder:

Being audited doesn't mean you're doing something wrong.

But you should make sure your telehealth workflows reflect current Medicare and payer requirements.


7. Time-Based Services

Any time reimbursement depends on time, documentation deserves additional attention.

Think about services such as:

  • Critical care
  • Prolonged services
  • Certain counseling services
  • Care-management services
  • Therapy services
  • Other time-dependent codes

If you're reporting a service that requires a defined amount of qualifying time, the documentation needs to support it under the applicable coding and payer rules.

Don't assume that adding:

“Total time: 45 minutes”

to the bottom of every note automatically supports the code.

The nature of the service and what activities count toward reported time matter.


8. Critical Care

Critical care deserves its own category.

Why?

Because high reimbursement combined with specific clinical and time requirements creates compliance risk when billing doesn't match the actual service.

Critical care isn't defined simply by:

ICU location.

A sick patient.

A serious diagnosis.

The record needs to support the patient's critical illness or injury, the practitioner's management, and the qualifying time required for the reported service.

Audit for:

  • Repeated identical critical-care times
  • Critical care reported for clinically stable patients
  • Procedure time counted improperly
  • Overlapping time
  • Missing documentation of critical illness or injury
  • Notes that describe routine care despite critical-care billing


9. Cloned Documentation

Copy and paste isn't automatically improper.

But cloned documentation can become a major compliance problem when it makes every patient look the same.

Yesterday:

Severe exacerbation. High risk. Extensive data reviewed.

Today:

Severe exacerbation. High risk. Extensive data reviewed.

Tomorrow:

Same thing.

Across 25 patients?

Now you should be asking questions.

Your documentation needs to represent what actually happened during that patient's encounter.

Templates should help physicians document care.

They shouldn't manufacture complexity.


10. Services Billed but Not Supported by the Record

This sounds obvious.

But it's one of the most fundamental audit risks.

If it's on the claim, you need documentation supporting it.

That includes:

  • Procedures
  • E/M services
  • Diagnostic tests
  • Drugs
  • Units
  • Supplies
  • Time
  • Modifiers
  • Laterality
  • Medical necessity

One of the simplest self-audit exercises is:

Medical Record → Code → Claim

Do all three tell the same story?

If not, investigate.


11. Excessive Units

Unit errors can become expensive quickly.

Suppose one drug is billed incorrectly.

Maybe the difference is only $40.

Nobody notices.

Now multiply it by:

20 patients a week.

52 weeks.

Multiple years.

A small unit error can turn into a significant overpayment.

Practices administering drugs, injections, infusions, biologics, or other unit-based services should routinely reconcile:

Purchased → Administered → Documented → Billed


12. Global Surgery Billing

Surgeons need to pay attention here.

A global surgical package doesn't mean everything occurring during the global period is automatically included.

But it also doesn't mean every postoperative encounter can be separately billed with a modifier.

That's why modifiers such as:

24

58

78

79

need to be used carefully and supported by documentation.

The risk comes when a modifier is used simply because:

“The claim won't pay without it.”

That's not a coding rationale.


13. Provider Enrollment and Who Actually Performed the Service

Compliance doesn't stop with CPT codes.

Who performed the service matters.

Who billed the service matters.

Which NPI was submitted matters.

Which organization received payment matters.

Where the service was performed can matter.

Enrollment relationships can matter.

Your medical record may be perfect while your claim is still incorrect because the wrong provider, location, billing entity, or enrollment relationship was reported.

That's why enrollment and credentialing belong in the compliance conversation—not just the administrative office.


14. Patterns That Don't Match Your Peers

This is where analytics becomes incredibly powerful.

Your practice should understand its own billing profile.

For example:

What percentage of your E/M visits are Level 4 or Level 5?

How often do you use Modifier 25?

How often do you use Modifier 59?

How frequently do you report critical care?

What procedures dominate your Medicare volume?

Which providers are statistical outliers?

None of these metrics independently proves wrongdoing.

Even OIG cautions in its telehealth program-integrity work that identifying high-risk billing characteristics does not itself establish fraud or an overpayment; further investigation is required. oig.hhs.gov

Data tells you where to look.

The medical record tells you whether there's actually a problem.


Don't Wait for OIG to Tell You What Your Data Says

This may be the biggest takeaway.

OIG has access to Medicare claims data.

Your practice has access to its own data.

So use it.

Run your own reports.

Look for your own outliers.

Audit your own documentation.

Compare your providers.

Review your modifiers.

Examine your high-dollar services.

Investigate unusual utilization.

OIG itself identifies internal monitoring and auditing as a core component of a physician compliance program. oig.hhs.gov


Build Your Own “Mini OIG Work Plan”

Once a year, sit down with your leadership, compliance, coding, and billing teams.

Ask:

Where is our highest compliance risk?

Then build an internal audit plan around it.

For example:

Q1: E/M levels and documentation

Q2: Modifier 25 and 59

Q3: Critical care and time-based services

Q4: Global surgery and incident-to billing

Then add focused audits whenever your analytics identify an unusual pattern.

That's much more effective than waiting until an external auditor asks for 50 charts.


And Don't Forget Your Billing Company

Your practice may outsource billing.

You don't outsource responsibility for knowing what is being submitted.

Ask your billing company:

Which modifiers are you adding to claims?

Are coders changing provider-selected codes?

What happens when a claim hits an NCCI edit?

How are coding-related denials handled?

Are claims ever changed simply to get them paid?

What coding trends are you seeing by provider?

What internal audits are you performing?

If the answer is:

“Don't worry. We handle all of that.”

That's not enough.


The Biggest Red Flag Isn't Finding an Error

It's finding an error and doing nothing about it.

If your self-audit identifies a problem:

Investigate it.

Determine the scope.

Identify the root cause.

Correct the workflow.

Provide education.

Determine whether affected claims or overpayments need to be addressed.

Re-audit.

For potentially significant findings, involve qualified compliance or healthcare legal counsel when appropriate.

A compliance program isn't measured by whether you ever make a mistake.

It's measured in large part by what you do when you discover one.


The Bottom Line

OIG isn't simply looking at whether a physician accidentally selected the wrong code one afternoon.

Government program-integrity efforts look for vulnerabilities, improper payments, unusual billing patterns, and areas where federal healthcare dollars may be at risk.

Your best defense is not fear.

It's visibility.

Know your numbers.

Know your coding patterns.

Know your modifiers.

Know what your documentation supports.

Know what your billing company is submitting.

And most importantly:

Audit yourself before someone else decides to audit you.

Because when an auditor asks why your billing looks different from everyone else's, the best answer isn't:

“We had no idea.”

It's:

“We know our data. We audit it. And our documentation supports what we bill.”

Have questions? Let's talk

We help medical practices simplify revenue cycle, coding, and compliance.

Get in touch